Sunday, April 3, 2011

42 BBY: Yaddle's Tale: The One Below

The One Below is one of my favorite Star Wars comic shorts. Tales Volume 2 was the first Tales trade paperback I bought and I remember reading it cover to cover and thoroughly enjoying it.

This story has a bunch of little elements to it that I really like. Firstly, I found Yaddle’s Master Polvin Kut an interesting Jedi.

Given to anger Kut fell to the dark side shortly before his head was ripped off by Advozsese warriors, which was an epically gruesome scene. Still harboring his hatred for Tulak, a warlock who killed his family, Master Kut gave into his rage and revenge, and received the results that such emotions reap.

What I find remarkable about this particular bit of the story was that Polvin was asked, presumably by the Jedi council, to be the one to deliver the colonies of Koba from Tulak. I suppose it was the council’s hope that Kut would be beyond such notions of revenge, and possibly sent him there as a test of his emotional detachment from the situation. Unfortunately for the Jedi Master, if this was the motivation of the council, he failed miserably.

The second little element of this story which I found neat was the mention of Tulak being a “warlock”: “Over two hundred years ago, The Jedi Knight Polvin Kut was summoned to liberate the colonies from the Advose warlock, Tulak”. My first instinct to this honorific was that it must’ve been a typo, and Vickie Williams (the letterer of this tale) really meant to write the word “warlord”, but through human error wrote “warlock”. Though with that being said I think the use of the title “warlock” for Tulak is vastly more intriguing. I hope it’s not an error, but intended, because it raises so many more interesting prospects for the Star Wars universe. The term “warlock” further supports the idea that Star Wars is really fantasy disguised as science fiction, and the idea of warlock warlord running around this universe only increases its mystery and danger.

The third element I found of interest was the introduction into Star Wars history of much of the Jedi council. I think this is the first time Evan Piel enters Star Wars chronology, along with many other Jedi Masters on the council. Even Piell has been one of those Jedi that has fascinated me since his first appearance in The Phantom Menace. I’ve always wondered about that little Jedi that has a resemblance to Master Yoda. I’m looking to forward to finding out more about him, which will make the Citadel trilogy from The Clone Wars that much more significant.

Moving along, I always find Yoda’s dogmatic nature a little amusing. When discussing Yaddle’s knighthood, Piell, Yaddle’s advocate on the council, had to contend with Yoda’s adherence to Jedi tradition: “Too old to resume the life of a Padawan she is, too much anger. A Jedi must complete her training. Another Master she needs”. Piell quickly strikes down Yoda’s assertion, and says the council is there to discuss her knighthood, not her re-training. After Piell’s re-telling of Yaddle’s story, Master Yoda softens his position, and he along with the other members of the council welcome her back into the Jedi order, but surprisingly not as a knight, but as a full-fledged Master.

Which brings me to the knighting ceremony; this is the first time in Star Wars history we have textual evidence of this ritual (I think prior to this Dooku mentions its “civility”), and boy, was it a plethora of lightsaber inaccuracies. I usually don’t get to upset by a Jedi with an improperly coloured lightsaber, as there are hundreds of ways to explain why a Jedi might have a lighsaber not their usual colour, but Yoda with a yellow saber? Mace with a blue one? Plo Koon with an orange saber? There were even a few red sabers in there for good measure. It was quite the rainbow. Still, it was neat to see how the Jedi go about promoting within their ranks.

My final point in regards to the comic short The One Below has to do with the main protagonist herself: Yaddle is the Jedi Master I’ve been waiting for: a peaceful, patient, and humble Jedi only drawn into combat as a last resort. A teacher and a healer before she is a warrior, she is one who loves her enemies as herself- the model of unselfish love. No wonder she went straight from Padawan to Master. She gained enlightenment in that hole, and rose from the darkness of death and solitude as a bright and enlightened Buddha.

For my next post I’m going to engage with The Deadly Hunter, book 11 in the Jedi Apprentice series. I’ll also deal with Hate Leads to Lollipops sometime soon as well. Hopefully I can keep my 7 post streak up for the month of April, but this month is crazy busy. Until then my friends, may the Force be with you.


  1. About the lightsabers, I think when this story was written, it hadn't yet been established that only Sith use red blades or that Mace has a purple blade. A retcon was established to explain away Mace's blade color (and has been applied elsewhere as well), the Concordance of Fealty (
    Also, here's a heads up: there's another section in Jedi vs. Sith (pages 66-67) that takes place in 42 BBY, so it's before The Deadly Hunter.

  2. Before Episode II established the colours of the lightsabers for the Jedi Council, they were quite a rainbow in comics and book covers. I don't usually make a big wuss of them being different colour in different sources, that has happened often in Star Wars. Mostly those differences have been classifies as "artistical".

    Yaddle's story is great one, and I want to see if she has more appearances in later sources (Jedi Quest 6 by Jude Watson is one I have read several times). Even Piell reminds me of Alastor Moody from Harry Potter, the way he casually spoke about deaths in Citadel trilogy was interesting. There is no death, they say...

    Thanks for the heads up, Plaristes, I had also missed that one. Going to read that now.

  3. Yeah, rookie mistake. I'm usually pretty good about looking at publication dates, so I don't know why I didn't look at the date of this tale and put two and two together.

    To echo Lugija's comment, thanks for the heads up on the next source. I'll make a stop back at Jedi vs. Sith before I move on to The Deadly Hunter.

  4. The grizzled veteran has always been an archetype I've enjoyed: they've seen it all, done it all, and always remain unflappable in the heat of battle. Both Alastor Moody and Even Piell have that 'hard boiled', 'this isn't my first rodeo' persona going on, and both are as ugly as sin.

  5. Just today I found the Timeline Checklist from, and decided to share it. It's a 50-page pdf with a very nice list of different media in chronological order. It even has "holorecords" from Jedi vs. Sith listed. But it has some of the dates different than the one you (and I) use (Jedi Apprentice 11-13 are 43 BBY, for example), so better to use it just as a checklist, for which it is very good.

  6. That's a great resource Lugija. I've saved it and I'll use it as a cross-reference to Joe's timeline. Thanks for pointing this out to me.

  7. A quote I'd like to share that, although not Jedi in origin, i think sums up their philosophy well. "The greatest victory is the battle not fought."